The MOTTA (Misappropriation of the Term Adventure) Awards 2004 – Article

Articles

by Agustin Cordes
Arranged
and created by Ben Bowen

February 22, 2005


Be honest, what is the first thing that comes to your mind when
you hear the word ‘adventure’? Exciting stories, faraway lands, fine
leather jackets? Or maybe wild creatures, long lost treasures, ancient
artifacts, fantastic items beyond your wildest dreams? Ladies in
distress? Danger? Drama?

If the answer is “yes”, then this article isn’t for
you.

For the first time ever (and because the world is clearly in bad need of them),
we’re proud to bring you the…

MOTTA Awards 2004
or
“Misappropriation Of The Term Adventure Awards 2004”

Forget about the Oscars! This is the single most awaited article of the past
months about what will become the most discussed event of the internet for days
to come. Yes, even more than global warming. It will shatter the foundations
of the game industry, shock the audience, and even change the sexual preference
of some people.
You’ve been warned mister! We are angry. And merciless.

Allow me to explain.

Once upon a time, when the world was a better place to live in and there was
love and beauty, the adventure genre existed. You could buy anything referred
to as an ‘adventure’ with confidence, knowing what kind of game to expect as
you more or less know what
to expect when you rent a Jess Franco movie. The birds sang and everything
was golden.

Now we have been boned. It’d seem someone has decided the ‘adventure’ name has
such a wide meaning, it can used to categorize anything that doesn’t fit under
any of the other popular genres. Worse, some of the games featured in this article
doesn’t even follow this logic
(ie: you have downright plain action games). But why, why did they choose
this poor genre to be massacrated? Why doesn’t anybody use ‘shooter’ to label
both Doom and R-Type? Oh no sir, those respected and important
games need to be properly labeled, hence the difference between ‘first-person
shooter’ and plain ‘shooter’. Nobody cares about the adventure genre anymore,
so let’s spread our foul message all over the world! There is such madness plaguing
this
industry that someone has to do something about it. So we here at Just Adventure+ have
decided to
grant the glorious MOTTA Awards, our response to the increasing carelessnes
showed
by many sites.

Basically, we decide which were the most outrageous misappropriations of the
‘adventure’ term during the previous year and then we proceed to ridicule and
make fun of the sites
found most deserving of a MOTTA Award. Obviously, the bulk of the article
will
be the most “notorious” adventure game of the year awards, although there might
be other particular cases (you’ll have to read on and find out for yourself –
be warned
though, it’s excruciating). Of course, the “winners” will be properly notified.
You will remember what the ‘adventure’ name stands for. You will remember us. (manic
laughter here)

A little bit of background considering this is our first issue: the term MOTTA was
coined up by fellow writer Ben Bowen and the winners chosen after an extensive
voting campaign on the Just Adventure+ forums. The number of voters was
astonishing – no more than eighty. Evidently nobody wanted to waste too much
time on this. And I can see where they’re coming from. Anyways, the one who agreed
to do the dirty job, which is writing about these insulting awards (not ours,
mind you, theirs), is yours truly.

Let’s get this over with, shall we.


5.
Sid Meier’s Pirates!

Developer/Publisher: Firaxis/Atari
The case for: Awarded “Adventure Game Of The Year”
Perpetrator: PC IGN


It’s just a slightly more dramatic alternative of “insult
sword fighting”, but that doesn’t mean it can’t be an adventure
game.
Ever
since Secret Of Monkey Island was released in the
early 90’s that pirates have become a recurring theme in
adventure games. And deservedly so, as few subjects can rival
the excitement and dramatic experience of taking on the role
of a pirate. Saddly, SOMI was missing something –
due to the technical limitations of the era, our beloved Guybrush
Threepwood
couldn’t engage on the sort of great fights
you get to see in the movies. Thankfully, Pirates! has
come back to mend all the problems that plagued SOMI,
tossing away the childish nature of the game and awful features
(ha-ha who in his right mind would believe real pirates engaged
on that sort of dumb insulting) in favor of a more dynamic
gameplay.
Breathe…
in… out…

Here goes a piece of advice to you guys – you see, nobody actually associates
‘science-fiction’ with spaceships and UFO’s anymore. You can also have
killer robots, time-travel, amazon women on the moon, and so on. Analogously,
nobody any longer associate ‘adventure’ with Goonies and pirates.
Yes, PIRATES! So that doesn’t mean you can declare a game an adventure
if it has pirates in it, you understand?!

On the other hand, maybe you misinterpreted the Dance Dance wannabe
sequences as some new form of innovative and exciting puzzles. If so,
my apologies.


4.
Metroid Prime 2: Echoes

Developer/Publisher: Retro/Nintendo
The case for: Awarded “Adventure Game Of The Year”
Perpetrator: VGManiacs

When
I came to this point while writing the article, I had to
pause. I was completely blocked. I panicked, trying to figure
out what was wrong with me. Yes, it was 2:00 AM but the liter
of coffee I had during the last half-hour should’ve been
enough. Then I realized what happened. I had absolutely no
idea what to say. I am, in fact, still trying to figure out
what thing… moment… minimal detail made VGManiacs declare Metroid
Prime 2: Echoes
the adventure game of the year. Maybe
they misinterpreted shooting the creatures as puzzles. Or…
I think I got it! Sometimes you need to carefully calculate
jumping between platforms – clearly an indicative of a meditative
and thoughtful type of gameplay, a notorious trademark of
the adventure genre.

Mutiplayer support – check. Varied arsenal of weapons – check.
Freaky aliens hunting you – check. Yessire, an adventure
game alright!
Or
maybe… maybe the way in which you have to cleverly select
the right weapon to combat your fierce opponents. Yes, that
has to be it – that and how you must find the weak point
of the end-level boss. Battling the mean bosses is definitely
one the most enjoyable moments in adventure games.

Sigh…

Please, either bring back Infocom or hand me a shotgun to blow
my brains out. I’ll do anything, even auction my mother on eBay to
clear the sullied and trashed ‘adventure’ name.


3.
Leisure Suit Larry: Magna Cum Laude & Silent Hill 4

Developer/Publisher: High
Voltage/Sierra & Konami
The case for: Both labeled as adventure games
Perpetrator: GameSpot


What’s wrong with you? Can’t you see that’s good-old
Larry’s nephew playing some sort of drinking minigame in
this fine and traditional adventure game?
It’s
always relieving witnessing the commendable work carried
on by huge websites like GameSpot. Perhaps one of
the biggest problems of the ‘jack-of-all-trades’ type of
sites like GameSpot is to provide accurate definitions
for all the games they cover. It makes sense if you think
about it, as they have a wide variety of readers – people
enjoying different types of games, be it strategy, real-time
strategy, first-person shooter, stealth/action… Yes, they
clearly describe some games as being stealth/action. So it
comes as no surprise when they define LSL: Magna Cum Laude and Silent
Hill 4
as… well, adventures.
You
surely heard about both these games but in case you live
in some kind of bubble let me tell you these are some of
the finest representatives of the adventure genre. Take Magna
Cum Laude
for instance – you take the role of a horny
teenager which desperately needs to score with some chicks.
To achieve this, you must solve some clever minigames, reminiscent
of some of the finest puzzles implemented by Magnetic
Scrolls
during the dawn of our beloved genre. Come on,
it’s exactly what Al Lowe did with Leisure Suit
Larry
(the one actually starring Larry Laffer)
a few years ago, except this time they slightly changed the
approach. Don’t be narrow-minded, kids – if GameSpot says
so, it must be an adventure.

Or what about Silent Hill 4? Right from the beginning, when the
first hound from hell shows up, you know this is going to be a rad adventure
game. Thankfully, the Silent Hill series have evolved a little
this time, focusing on killing the zombies and evil creatures alike instead
of solving boring puzzles. Let’s hope the remaining bunch of old-fashioned
adventure developers out there jump on this bandwagon, improving their
pathetic outdated games with those kind of thrilling, edge-of-your-seat
sequences.

Oh please…

At least I’m somewhat relieved that Silent Hill 4 is the closest
thing to an adventure featured in this article… if you cut out a good
80% of the whole game. But don’t get me started on Magna Cum Laude.
Look, just because it’s some sort of sequel to an adventure franchise,
it doesn’t mean it has to be one. That does make kind of sense, does
it? Maybe Just Adventure+ isn’t the ultimate authority in the
genre, but at least we labeled Magna Cum Laude as an arcade game
(an archaic but still useful little word). Oh and Silent Hill 4 as
survival horror or action/adventure – which is exactly what it is.


2.
Gish

Developer/Publisher: Chronologic
The case for: Awarded “Adventure Game Of The Year” and
they even had the face to post their own hilarious definition
of adventure games
Perpetrator: Game Tunnel

It
is of vital importance that we read this accurate definition
of adventure games to understand the weight of this award:
“Game Tunnel defines adventure games as either platform games,
think Super Mario Bros. (Charlie II for indie purists), or action
games that are heavier on the storyline and lighter on the action
(those that have RPG aspects, but aren’t really RPGs).”

Now I can finally rest in peace, knowing that whenever I need to identify
an adventure I’ll always have this fantastic and all-encompassing definition
at hand.

Lord, grant me strength…


Geez guys, you got me worried there for a one second
thinking this was a platformer! But now I can see I was
wrong and pushing your blob around tiled levels with time
limits and stuff is clearly a sign of a classic adventure
game.
This
really borders on the insulting. Not only they dished years
of gaming history with their amateurish definition, they’re
actually contemplating the possibility of purists in it.
Can’t you see the “real” adventure genre is the only one
admitting purists? Return what belongs to us! What’s worse,
games like Gish have been called platformers for like…
well, since ever!

If I had my way, I’d force them to play Super Mario Bros. for
the rest of their lives with headphones and have the volume crammed up.
Let’s see if you take that lame game so seriously after you listen those
dreaful tunes a few hundred times. I understand it’s the equivalent to
Chinese water torture after the first 48 hours. One more week, and it
becomes mortal. Talk about adventure!


1.
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

Developer/Publisher: Rockstar
The case for: Awarded “Adventure Game Of The Year”
Perpetrator: 1UP


A most shocking display of that glorious moment in adventure
games when you can finally paint the walls with the insides
of a threatening old man using your handy shotgun.
Ah
the adventurous feeling of bludgeoning someone to death!
Running old ladies over with your kick-ass car. Hanging out
with hookers. Robbing banks. Listening to rap music. Hell, GTA can
be already considered a synonym of ‘adventure’ – and 1UP is
well aware of it!

Of course, we’re talking about none other than GTA: San Andreas,
the game that has been highly anticipated by adventurers all over the
world. It happens to be the sequel to GTA: Vice City, the immensely
successful game which arguably revived the adventure genre. What makes
this collection of bytes such a wonderful experience?

Easy
– the hi-octane gameplay making your adrenaline burst through
your nerves as most adventures do. Because let’s face it,
running through a virtual city with your trusty Uzi like
a madman has always been the cornerstone, the essence of
what consitutes the adventure game. However, just like in Vice
City
, the concept has been greatly sophisticated, as
players have to take part in missions. Missions! No wonder
the genre was dying until the GTA franchise showed
up with its innovative design. So the killing is organized
into missions (which in reality behave as puzzles) cleverly
integrated within the storyline. As if that wasn’t enough,
players can ride a huge variety of vehicles. Cars, jeeps,
speedboats, planes, bikes (bikes!), you name it.

Some may accuse Rockstar of not trying to push the envelope once
again with this new instalment in the series but hey, they’ve already
broadened the horizons of the adventure genre, so why fix what’s broken?
I mean, fix what’s not broken. Wait a minute… whatever, you know what
I mean. Anyway, I’m at a loss for words here. Can’t do anything but nod
in approval at the excellent job done by 1UP with their acknowledgement
of GTA: San Andreas as the adventure game of the year. Hats off
to you sirs! Yeah…

That’s it!

We’re absolutely speechless, stunned, annoyed, indignated, obliterated,
disgustipated at the bizarre award handled to GTA: San Andreas as
the adventure game of the year. 1UP has more or less raped and
left King Graham bleeding to death in a dirty sewer. Thank you,
you have killed our childhood and everything pure and innocent in this
God-forsaken world. It’s sites like this (and the above) one of the things
doing so much harm to the adventure genre these days. This is a very
serious issue, as it hurts developers and dedicated publishers alike.
Now tell me how ‘real’ adventure game reviewers shall explain to newcoming
readers why in Syberia Kate Walker can’t shoot Momo or Oscar in
the forehead. I mean yes, more than a few would love to do that… but
that’s not the point! You sirs, have totally missed the point.

But panic not! From our humble but cozy place at Just Adventure+ we’re
intending to revert this with our shiny new MOTTA Awards. This
is only the beginning. Heads will roll. Oh yes, they will.


Well, that’s all folks!
We hope you enjoyed our first issue of the MOTTA Awards.
Don’t send me hate mail, I’m just the writer! Make sure you read
us again next year when Quake IV is hailed as the adventure
game of the year. Wooh boy, what a riot that’s going to be!

Now if you’ll excuse me, I’ll go cut my veins with a spoon.

admin