Just Adventure News : Press Release: Divines of the East Class Spotlight: Sword Saint Press Release: Green Man Gaming Signs Up Award-Winning Telltale Games Gold: 'Reus' released Press Release: The Swapper Steam Release Date and New Trailer Press Release: Lost Spirits of Kael Game: Magicka - Wizard Wars First-Ever Screenshots Revealed Game: Dutch designers break new ground with audio game Remembering Press Release: Gamebook Fans Unite! Beta: Start of the Second WildStar Closed Beta Game: Jack Haunt - Old Haunting Grounds
Home - Forum Home
Welcome Guest, please Login or Register!
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register or login before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Topic: Nancy Drew: Blackmoor Manor

    Page 1

All Forums : [Member Arena] : Members' Adventure Game Reviews > Nancy Drew: Blackmoor Manor
2 OCT 2004 at 2:30am

KingRyan

Sorcerer Apprentice
Sorcerer Apprentice



Posts : 281
Joined: 25 JAN 2004

Status : Online
Nancy Drew:
Curse of Blackmoor Manor

AROUND THE WORLD IN 11 GAMES
Nancy’s first international adventure begins in London, England, where she is called upon to meet her old neighbor, now-married Linda Penvellyn. Linda has been acting a bit strange lately and her parents are worried, so our intrepid Miss Drew volunteers to see what’s wrong.

This game is billed as the spookiest game yet, and its only competitor (Message in a Haunted Mansion) is certainly no competition, for the most part. There are dark passageways and scary creatures that you will encounter during the game that really add to atmosphere. The opening sequence may even have you on the edge of your seat, as well as some of the nightmares Nancy has. The visuals are stunning, as are all the graphics. Everything is crisp, clear, and beautiful. Interface is the same as it has been; some have minor quibbles, but overall it gives you a larger view of the game itself.

But the best word to describe the game from here is ‘uncomfortable,’ as if the developers weren’t sure what to do at times and took a tentative step forward. Let me explain why.

WORKING HARD OR HARDLY WORKING?
The puzzles are one of the weakest aspects of the game. They are much like some of the challenges presented in Stay Tuned for Danger, in which answers are provided by hidden codes and riddles spread throughout nooks and crannies instead of straightforward. In the beginning, there are some really mediocre puzzles where somebody simply didn’t jump on the logic train. One involves you roaming the manor at night searching for holographic ghosts that are hidden on walls and floors only at that time. There was no sense to the puzzle and why it was there, or how somebody would set up something like that.

As the game progresses, the puzzles get harder and cleverer, requiring you to take notes on every chart, diagram, and book you can get your hands on. The real stumper is a rotating room, just like in Mystery of the Mummy. I’m not sure that this is really something for a 10-year-old to be solving, but experienced gamers will enjoy the scent of a challenge!

BRRRAACCKK! BRRRAACCKK!
Whoever fell asleep in the puzzle design department for the previous game (- thanks, Ray!), Secret of Shadow Ranch, apparently passed on the epidemic to the voice actors. The dialogue is pretty poor for a Nancy Drew game. When seeing a photo of a girl’s dead hamster, Nancy literally yells at her, “You had a hamster?! When?!” as if this is a new concept to her. Loulou, the parrot, squawks, “Don’t leave me! I love you!” in a voice strangely similar to Cartman from South Park. The other actors simply don’t put much enthusiasm into anything they say, and Mrs. Drake is probably the best of them all, with her authentic British nanny accent.

The other problem with dialogue is that sometimes Nancy’s words are easy to hear but the other person appears to be speaking softly. You have to put your ear to the speaker in order to hear them, which is a nuisance. This also happens with the music; I think I went through the whole game without hearing a single note.

SCOOBY-DOO, WHERE ARE YOU?
By the end of the game, we have been treated to a Scooby-Doo potpourri of witches, werewolves, gargoyles, knights, and suspicious robed figures in black. By then most of it has become incredibly hard to swallow, especially when Nancy starts to believe some of it. The ending does not wrap up everything, and is rather disappointing, again as if it was just too much to create a more logical mystery.

Overall, a satisfying game – but Her Interactive has done better.

FINAL GRADE: B

[size=14][b]Currently Playing:[/b]&&Sherlock Holmes: Nemesis[/size]

Profile Search


2 OCT 2004 at 12:53pm

Ivinia

Guild Master
Guild Master



Posts : 4459
Joined: 7 JUN 2003
Location: US

Status : Offline
Ryan - Let me hopefully be the first to congratulate you on this review!  I really like how you described issues you weren't happy with.  Too often we see reviews that are vague in regards to parts being bad without elaborating on them.  From my standpoint as a reader, I have to say you were quite clear on what parts you didn't like and were successful in explaining why without giving too much away.

Having read your past reviews, I have to say it is fun watching you evolve and develop your talents!

Great job!!   [smiley=clap.gif]


Profile Search
2 OCT 2004 at 1:25pm

KingRyan

Sorcerer Apprentice
Sorcerer Apprentice



Posts : 281
Joined: 25 JAN 2004

Status : Online
Thank you very much!  

[size=14][b]Currently Playing:[/b]&&Sherlock Holmes: Nemesis[/size]

Profile Search
13 NOV 2004 at 5:50pm

gmadam

Intergalactic Janitor
Intergalactic Janitor



Posts : 3
Joined: 13 NOV 2004

Status : Online
I played ND-BM a few weeks ago and had problems with it too. I actually liked Lou Lou the parrot - my favorite line was, "I think we need a bigger boat" (from the movie Jaws). I enjoyed most of the puzzles that require the player to work from various clues and figure out the puzzle using logic. But my big problem with the game were the ridiculous timed puzzles - typing, jigsaw puzzle, and the big one for me - pouring the oil into the hole in the floor in the great hallway. No matter how many times I tried, I could not get that puzzle. I got all my movements down exactly and clicked on the hotspot over the hole and Nancy would say something about having  to try again. Because I couldn't get past this puzzle I never got to finish the game.

After installing the game I chose "Senior Detective" (which I always do) but was not able to get past the typing puzzle. So uninstalled the game (my saved games weren't removed), reinstalled the game, chose "Junior Detective," and was able to get past the typing puzzle. Unfortunately, it still didn't give me enough time to finish the "oil in the hole in the floor" puzzle - a real disappointment for me.    [smiley=hair_pull.gif]

Profile Search
13 NOV 2004 at 8:57pm

Mikekelly

Private Detective
Private Detective



Posts : 612
Joined: 25 JUN 2004

Status : Offline

I've only played one ND game - "Ghost Dogs" which was excellent - but I've also got the Nancy Drew game for the GBA which may be fun.

It seems like the older ones are better than the new ones from the reviews I'v read.




Profile Search
28 NOV 2004 at 8:16pm

KingRyan

Sorcerer Apprentice
Sorcerer Apprentice



Posts : 281
Joined: 25 JAN 2004

Status : Online
Click the small link in my signature to see the cool promo trailer!
[size=14][b]Currently Playing:[/b]&&Sherlock Holmes: Nemesis[/size]

Profile Search
All Forums : [Member Arena] : Members' Adventure Game Reviews > Nancy Drew: Blackmoor Manor

    Page 1

Jump to:
0 Members Subscribed To This Topic