Just Adventure News : Addon: Legacy of Romulus Expansion to Star Trek Online Launches Game: Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment wishes gamers Good Night, Good Luck in Dying Light Beta: Second Phase of Eldevin Closed Beta Begins News: Video Games: The Movie Press Release: Indie Narrative / Strategy Game 7 Grand Steps Will Release June 7 for PC and Mac Gold: The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing Demo: Jack Haunt: Old Haunting Grounds Alpha Demo Released Game: Might And Delight Presents "Shelter" Early Gameplay Footage Press Release: Legendary Monsters Are Invading Age of Conan Press Release: New Settler and Scientist Path content for WildStar
Home - Forum Home
Welcome Guest, please Login or Register!
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register or login before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Topic: The top 50 adventure games of all time

    Page 3 of 3 : «

All Forums : [Member Arena] : Members' Adventure Game Reviews > The top 50 adventure games of all time
28 DEC 2004 at 8:07pm

The_cranky_hermit

Private Detective
Private Detective



Posts : 547
Joined: 14 MAR 2004

Status : Online
#1: Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers

Gabriel Knight is considered by many to be the pinnacle of adventure games made by Sierra, a company that frequently innovated, took chances, and pushed the adventure genre into realms where others wouldn’t dare. Gabriel Knight, with solid writing, convincing artwork and graphics, professional acting, nearly insane attention to detail, and one of the most intense and fascinating storylines ever written, is a prime example of an experiment done right.

At the start, we’re introduced to Gabriel and his miserable life. After a cut-scene showing a re-occuring nightmare, we see his mundane and gloomy world. He lives in a cluttered, one room studio, runs a doomed bookstore, and is up to his neck in debt. We’ve all experienced failure before, and because of this, we can relate to Gabriel far better than we can relate to the heroic and resourceful Sir Graham, the cartoonish Guybrush Threepwood, or even the ever-popular AFGNCAAP hero.

Before being thrown headfirst into the complex and gripping plot, the player must explore various parts of New Orleans. Here, the amazing amount of detail becomes obvious. Every object in the game can be “looked” at, and nearly all of them are described with great detail. Because the game takes place in New Orleans, there are many characters who know about Voodoo. They all have much to say on the subject if questioned. The dialogue system is one of the most incredible systems seen in an adventure game; when you speak to another character, you can select and discuss various subjects. As Gabriel learns more information, the range of topics widens. Discussions about Voodoo in particular show the results of months of intense research on the subject. All this detail makes the setting feel realistic, and makes the plot far more believable (and disturbing), than if it had depicted Voodoo with all the authenticity of Monkey Island 2.

Then the plot is hurled at you, a fog of direness envelops, and it doesn’t clear up until the game’s finale. You stumble on a grisly post-murder scene at a grimy lake shore, one in a series of gruesome ritualistic underworld killings. Etched into the sand around the victim are mostly illegible Voodoo markings, which the police write off as a red herring. Gabriel, dabbling in hack writing, is mostly interested in researching the murders as a source for his novel, but quickly becomes deeply involved in the mystery, and must confront not only the murderous circles of the present, but also the demons of his past.

With the exception of a few technical bugs inherent in Sierra’s SCI system, this is a game that does everything right. It has a moody, atmospheric soundtrack, excellent voice acting, diverse and identifiable characters, detailed, realistic graphics, and a remarkable and thought-provoking storyline.

Profile Search


28 DEC 2004 at 8:44pm

The_cranky_hermit

Private Detective
Private Detective



Posts : 547
Joined: 14 MAR 2004

Status : Online
And now, some facts and statistics about the list:

The list covers 23 years of adventure games, from 1980 (#12: Zork) to 2002 (#10: Syberia, #33: Dark Fall).

The #1 game on the list, Gabriel Knight, won by a very large margin of 9 points.

LucasArts is the most represented by this list; 11 of their adventure games appear on the list. Sierra has 8.

Three trilogies have made the list entirely (Gabriel Knight, Myst, Monkey Island). At the time the list was started, Myst IV had not come out, qualifying it as a trilogy at the time.

Gabriel Knight is by far the best recieved trilogy, all three appear in the top ten.

41 games, the vast majority, exclusively (or nearly exclusively) use a point and click interface. 5 games rely much on keyboard control. 3 games use a typing interface for everything. The one remaining game is Leisure Suit Larry 7 (#45), and it uses both point&click and typing.

33 games use a third person perspective. 15 games are first person. Zork (#12) is all text. The Last Express (#13) frequently changes perspective and neither can really be called the chief perspective.

1996 was the most represented year, with 9 games on the list. 1997 followed strong with 7.

15 games on the list are sequels (#39: Indiana Jones & the Last Crusade is not one of them, even though it's called Indy3). Mean Streets is the only game with sequels on the list (#42: Under a Killing Moon, #28: The Pandora Directive) that does not appear on the list itself.

10 games on the list appear in HOTU's Hall of Belated Fame.

6 games on the list were considered "Historically Significant."

The highest ranking game that scored points entirely from popularity was Riven (#25).

Year quintiles:
9 games on the list were released between 1980 and 1991.
10 games on the list were released between 1992 and 1994.
13 games on the list were released on 1995 or 1996.
9 games on the list were released on 1997 or 1998.
9 games on the list were released between 1999 and 2002.

Profile Search
28 DEC 2004 at 10:48pm
Deleted UserGreat work, Cranky!

Now onto that top 50 list of cheese. Although if Edam is anywhere on it I'd have to question the integrity of such a rundown.

29 DEC 2004 at 2:42am

DJ Souza

Journeyman
Journeyman



Posts : 1452
Joined: 19 OCT 2002

Status : Online
Great work, everyone! And thanks a lot for the whole list idea, Cranky! It sure has been fun![smiley=detective.gif]

In case this thread goes to the JA+ archive, here are some interesting links worth mentioning to those who missed the whole thing:

Top 50 Adventure Games of All Time - Titles only

Discuss the top 50 adventure games list

History of Top 50 adventures
[center]DIEGO J. SOUZA&&Consulting Detective for Hire[img]http://www.justadventure.com/public_html/YaBBImages/smilies//detective.gif[/img]&&&&[img]http://img78.photobucket.com/albums/v249/Fairygdmther/Avatars/A-G-E-S_SIG.jpg[/img][/center]

Profile Search
30 DEC 2004 at 3:54pm

Anne

Guild Master
Guild Master



Posts : 4800
Joined: 8 MAR 2003

Status : Online
I have just posted to apologise to Cranky Hermit.I offered to review TLJ and really love this game.I now have 17 pages of handwritten notes and several sleepless nights.
I really can`t do this and admire all those who did.
My apologies to everyone. :'(

Profile Search
30 DEC 2004 at 5:53pm
Deleted UserAnne: just post your 17 pages of notes, it'll be like an experimental review  
. There is no Pulitzer at stake, and beside everybody already knows how grandiose TLJ is...


All Forums : [Member Arena] : Members' Adventure Game Reviews > The top 50 adventure games of all time

    Page 3 of 3 : «

Jump to:
0 Members Subscribed To This Topic